The Christmas tree is the central symbol of the holidays, creating warmth and joy. But when it comes time to make a decision - natural or artificial - we often find ourselves in a dilemma. Is an artificial tree really more ecological in the long term, or does it naturally have a lower impact on the environment? We've researched for you which choice is best for the planet and checked out some interesting alternatives.
Is it better to put natural tree or artificial, which you have been using for a decade? We reveal ecological truths and alternatives.
Natural Christmas Tree: Scent of the woods with a limited shelf life
Natural trees, most often firs or spruces, are synonymous with a festive atmosphere. Their main advantage is that they absorb carbon dioxide during growth, produce oxygen and support local biodiversity. After cutting, they can be composted or used as mulch.
Advantages of natural trees:
- Biodegradability: After the holidays, you can compost or recycle them.
- Local production: Many natural trees come from local plantations, reducing the transport carbon footprint.
- Freshness and fragrance: A natural tree brings a unique smell of the forest.
But this choice is not completely without problems. Growing natural trees often involves pesticides and fertilizers that harm the environment. In addition, mass production means trees are cut months before the holidays, which can affect their freshness.
Artificial Christmas tree: A long-term investment with an initial environmental burden
Artificial trees promise practicality and longevity. With proper care, you can use them for ten years or more, which reduces the need for an annual purchase. But they are made of plastic and metal, which means a large carbon footprint during production and transport.
Advantages of artificial trees:
- Long life: If you use an artificial tree for more than ten years, its environmental impact decreases.
- Practicality: There is no waste and no worries about watering or dropping needles.
- Various options: Trees of all sizes, colors and shapes are available.
However, artificial trees will never be biodegradable. When we throw them away, they end up in landfills where they remain for centuries. If they are manufactured in distant countries, their carbon footprint is further increased due to transportation.
Which is more organic?
Although an artificial tree promises longevity, studies show that you need to use such a tree for at least 10-20 years to equalize its impact with a natural one. If you compost a natural tree after use, its environmental friendliness is significantly greater.
Alternatives for a sustainable celebration
Alternatives are also available for those looking for more innovative solutions:
- A tree in a pot: Buy a tree with roots to plant or keep in the garden after the holidays.
- DIY trees: Trees made of natural materials such as wood, twigs or paper are a creative and sustainable solution.
- Christmas tree rental: Some providers allow you to rent a tree in a pot, which you return after the holidays.
What to choose?
Choosing between a natural and an artificial tree depends on your priorities. If the smell of the forest is important to you and you want to support local growers, the natural tree is a great choice. If you swear by practicality and long-term use, consider an artificial tree. Alternative options like potted or DIY trees are great for anyone who wants to be creative and environmentally conscious.
Key tip: Whatever you choose, do the right thing after the holidays and reduce waste. This way, you will end the holidays with a smaller burden on the environment.
